Skip to content
Axe Capital logo Axe Capital Trading News

If a Downturn Is Coming, 50 Years of Market History Says This Is the Single Best Response

2026-09-05 15:15 Reuben Gregg Brewer The Motley Fool Positive Axe Cap view: Selective ForexEquities BRK.ABRK.BVOOSPY

Axe Cap view

Why Sitting Tight Beats Trying to Time a Downturn

A look at why history and Buffett agree that doing nothing in a market crash often wins.

South African investors fret whenever the rand spikes or global headlines signal recession fears. The takeaway from 50 years of the US market, championed by Buffett's steady hand at Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.A, BRK.B), is surprisingly simple: don’t panic. The data shows selling during downturns locks in losses, while staying invested — or even buying through regular contributions to low-cost trackers like an S&P 500 ETF (think VOO or SPY) — smooths out the ride and boosts returns over time. For local investors, that translates into resisting the urge to dump positions in Prosus or Naspers when USD/ZAR rattles higher. Yes, the rand's volatility stings, and yes, local economic risks exist, but market timing remains a fool's errand. The risk? A sudden, prolonged economic shock could drip-feed pain longer than the patience of many. Still, history and Buffett’s approach argue that temperament beats timing every time. this is just our opinion and not financial advice

How I would invest

Maintain core exposure to leading JSE tech counters like Naspers and Prosus and consider modest monthly buys of S&P 500 trackers to benefit from dollar-cost averaging. Avoid knee-jerk reactions to rand swings unless fundamentals shift drastically.

What I would watch
  • Naspers
  • Prosus
  • VOO
  • USD/ZAR
What could go wrong
  • prolonged local economic downturn
  • sharp rand depreciation beyond current levels
How strongly I feel

7/10

The article argues that the best investment strategy during market downturns is to do nothing and maintain a long-term buy-and-hold approach. Drawing on 50 years of S&P 500 history and Warren Buffett's philosophy, it recommends dollar-cost averaging through regular index fund purchases while avoiding market timing, emphasizing that temperament and discipline matter more than intelligence in investing.

Our take is based on reporting first published by The Motley Fool.

Read the original story